CIEEM responds to the first Environmental Delivery Plan: “not fit for purpose” as drafted

CIEEM has submitted its response to Natural England’s consultation on the draft Norfolk Environmental Delivery Plan (EDP). We say the plan is not fit for purpose in its current form.

We encourage all members to submit their own responses to this consultation, which closes at 9:29am on Tuesday, 27 October 2026.

We welcome the Government’s willingness to explore strategic, landscape-scale approaches to nature recovery, and many of the conservation measures proposed would bring real benefits for habitats and the wider landscape. But it will also allow rare and sensitive protected habitats – already in dangerously poor condition and close to irreversible tipping points – to decline further before any recovery is delivered.

This is the first EDP, and it will be the template for those that follow. It has to work.

The pollution problem

The plan accepts that nutrient pollution entering the Broads and the River Wensum will still rise over its ten-year life of the EDP, even if every measure is delivered on time. By our reading of the annexes, roughly 83% of the nitrogen and 39-61% of the phosphorus from new development would remain in perpetuity. The EDP itself recognises that even small increases can push waterbodies past irreversible ecological tipping points, and every affected site is already in deteriorating condition.

Many of the proposed measures, such as deer management, hydrological improvements and fen management, do not directly reduce nutrients. Yet nutrient pollution is the limiting factor for recovery in the Broads. Habitat gains elsewhere cannot make up for it. The Overall Improvement Test relies on expert judgement and red-amber-green scoring, and it could be passed even where nutrient pressure increases.

Irreplaceable habitats

Grouping features into broad habitat categories hides the impacts on specialist species such as Fen Orchid and Milk Parsley. Lowland fen is an irreplaceable habitat as defined in the NPPF and BNG, and offering compensation for harm to it is not an appropriate response.

A levy that may not add up

The flat levy of £2,675 per dwelling looks too low to fund the measures listed. It is not linked to the nutrient load of individual developments, and the plan includes only a 5% contingency.

A tariff set too low risks leaving conservation measures unfunded, passing the bill to the taxpayer or future developers, and undercutting the private nutrient-credit schemes that already cut pollution.

This could deter investment in mitigation across the country, slowing the housebuilding that the EDP is meant to support.

What we are asking for

  • Upfront measures that cut pollution at source, including whole-farm agricultural change, nutrient-removing SuDS, septic tank upgrades and interceptor wetlands.
  • Assessment of individual species and irreplaceable habitats, not grouped categories.
  • A realistic, fully costed levy that does not undermine existing nature markets, with existing providers brought into the scheme.
  • Outcome-based monitoring, with clear thresholds for early corrective action.
  • A whole-catchment approach, including nutrient budgets, farming incentives and wastewater upgrades.
  • Limits on future EDPs: kept separate from Biodiversity Net Gain, not extended to species without robust evidence, and not applied where private markets already work.

CIEEM members are the ecologists who will be relied upon to deliver EDPs, and we want them to succeed. That is why we are pressing for changes now, before this approach is repeated elsewhere.

Read the full CIEEM response.