Consultation response: Nutrient pollution – draft Norfolk Environmental Delivery Plan consultation (Natural England) (27 October 2026)

CIEEM has responded to the Natural England consultation on the first draft Environmental Delivery Plan (EDP).

This first draft EDP is for housing in Norfolk and covers impacts from nutrient pollution.

CIEEM’s position is that the draft Norfolk EDP is not fit for purpose as drafted. This is important because it will be the template for future EDPs. CIEEM welcomes the strategic, landscape-scale approach and the nature-recovery measures, but not the pollution risk or the design of the levy.

Main concerns

  1. Residual pollution and tipping points: Even if every measure is delivered, nutrient inputs still rise. Roughly 83% of nitrogen and 39-61% of phosphorus loading would remain permanently. The EDP itself says small increases can push the Broads past irreversible tipping points, and all sites are already rated “red”.
  2. The Overall Improvement Test (OIT) is too weak: It uses red-amber-green scoring and expert judgement, and it lets gains in habitat or hydrology offset nutrient harm. Nutrient enrichment is the limiting factor for recovery, so those gains can’t compensate. The test can be passed even when nutrient pressure increases.
  3. Compensation rather than mitigation: Most proposed conservation measures (deer management, fen management, river restoration) don’t directly cut nutrients, and are mostly delivered after the impacts occur. Some may not be additional because they are existing obligations.
  4. Irreplaceable habitats and species: Grouping features into broad habitat categories masks impacts on specialists such as Fen Orchid and Milk Parsley. Lowland fen is irreplaceable, and compensating for harm to it is inappropriate.
  5. Discounted measures: Septic tank and package treatment plant upgrades, nutrient-removing SuDS, farm regime change and interceptor wetlands were rejected on weak or unevidenced grounds.
  6. The 15,780-dwelling cap and geographic scope: The figure is a forecast of housing demand and levy uptake, not an ecological capacity limit. The boundaries follow expected growth, not nutrient pathways.
  7. Levy and value for money: The £2,675 per dwelling flat rate is too low, with no intervention-level costings and only a 5% contingency. It doesn’t reflect the nutrient load of individual developments. It also risks undercutting existing private nutrient-credit markets, in Norfolk and nationally. And the Secretary of State can vary the tariff at any time.
  8. Back-up measures, longevity and governance: Back-up measures mostly repeat the primary ones, and triggers are qualitative. 100 years for the conservation measures is shorter than Natural England’s own credit schemes which are secured for 125 years. Natural England also holds many conflicting roles in designing, funding, delivering and assessing the plan.
  9. Monitoring: There is no meaningful detail on monitoring. It tracks delivery and spend rather than ecological outcomes, and the only formal reviews are at years 5 and 10.

Proposed solutions

  1. Add upfront source-control measures such as whole-farm pollution reduction, farming transition support, water-efficiency conditions, nutrient-removing SuDS, septic tank upgrades and interceptor wetlands.
  2. Assess impacts feature by feature, and protect irreplaceable habitats rather than compensating for them.
  3. Raise the levy to a realistic level, backed by published whole-life costings and independent review.
  4. Bring existing and future nutrient credit suppliers into the scheme rather than undermining them.
  5. Replace qualitative scoring with quantified nutrient budgets and outcome-based monitoring.
  6. Require, at a minimum, verified nutrient neutrality before occupation, with a fully costed contingency.
  7. Take a whole-catchment approach, including strict nutrient budgets, farming incentives and wastewater upgrades.
  8. Limit future EDPs. Keep them separate from BNG, don’t extend them to species without robust evidence, and don’t apply them where private markets already work.
  9. Secure mitigation by legally binding agreements, with greater separation of Natural England’s roles.